I can’t decide so I’ll say I have two favorites: cookies and cream or Neapolitan. Absolutely love both of these flavors.
Reviving this old thread to add my 2 cents. I really like a Weis Markets flavor called Malt & Salt of the Earth. Chocolate malt ice cream with salted caramel swirl and chocolate chunks. YUM!
100% it's going to be Ben and Jerry's Half-Baked.