[Avi]

* Snip Snip*

Your breakdown of each video presented describes almost exactly what I would have said, your analysis is spot on.

As a former prop hunter with thousands of hours across a few communities, I don't see anything that stands out in these videos as "weird gameplay" or "suspicious" with how Fofab goes around finding props.  You can see in every clip presented that he is checking every cheeky and very well known spot that players hide in, even some of the ones that only experienced players would know to check.  I will admit there were times I used to be suspicious of Fofab's gameplay as well, but looking back, a lot of it is just experienced gameplay on his part.

The maps in these videos are very common played maps on this server and others too.  I would reasonably expect that someone with that many hours would have great map/prop spawn knowledge (that's almost what got me banned the first time I ever played this server because I knew the map well and got 11 kills in two hunter rounds).  That being said, I think that answers a lot of the "how did he know the prop was there" questions that people ask.

Is there any other proof that shows more definitive examples of the suspected cheating?  I don't think there is anything here, and it would be unfair to keep Fofab banned on these videos alone.  I also don't agree with the ban reason "untrusted gameplay ban" either.  It implies there is no definitive proof of cheating, rather the ban was off of suspicion/hunch (which has never been a reason to ban someone).

+1 for full unban unless further proof is provided