[ReThink]

Weren't there already like two or three people supposedly working on remaking this map?

Anyway, as for a remake of dinkleberg I'd say go for it if you want.
For ideas? I'd suggest maybe taking the third house out, and put more focus on the turner and dinkleberg houses, make them larger and more accurate, just fleshing them out more. I'd also suggest using as much from the source material, the show, as you can/want. Like, for instance, make a traitor room that's the inside of cosmo and wanda's fish castle, that you go to by activating a teleporter connected to the fishbowl in timmy's room or something. Make magic or wish related traitor traps. Maybe have vicky's lemonade stand outside complete with her underground sweat shop dungeon. Have doug dimmadome's hat towering into the heavens off in the distance. Whatever, go crazy and have fun with it.

I also don't really understand what decision you want staff to make. You want to make a map, go ahead and make a map, no one can stop you there. Go ahead and get as much input and suggestions from staff and anyone else you think has good ideas you can pull off. As for replacing the current dinks? I'd say hold off on that discussion until your map is in a position to actually replace it.

It's more of a "not wanting to make an entire map and then be told we don't want to replace the old one" sort of thing. Quality maps take time, so it would really suck putting something together without staff approval and then have it rejected. My philosophy is to ask staff if they actually would be interested in such a proposition BEFORE I put time into it.