[Mr. EveryDay]

I'd say 2 years is TOO long for a threat, +1

Hmmmm.. almost like.... ban escalation is a problem on the server?
+1 because this dude shouldn't have been banned in the first place for more than a few days but moderation is too inconsistent and ban lengths are too extreme.

No need to bring your problem into this thread, this guy probably would've been unbanned in 6 months or less if he had just asked, which he didn't.
The Mods have every right to permaban people for serious threats, but that doesn't mean they won't have a change of heart after a few months