[KaptainLes]

So
This is a hacking ban appeal
Not a toxicity appeal.
Speedie was not banned for toxicity, albiet they were close to one.
But the ban was ultimately for hacking. Toxicity was not a factor.

I'd say that if unbanned speedie would be on similar footing - a couple toxic comments and they are gone.

That being said the question here is was speedie hacking.
The video is laggy. Is the laggy video good enough to sustain the ban?
One of our experts, Aethy, has weighed in saying the video is not sufficient quality. Our newest trusted, HONG (who has similar skills in sussing out hackers) also agrees that the video is too laggy. This is not to say that speedie did or didn't hack. But that the proof presented was not good enough.

Other experts feel the video shows a lock. I initially agreed with this assessment back in November. However, given my status as an expert in laggy video (see any video I've ever posted), I think the video should be discounted in areas of lag. People can have good aim too.

This will be updated with my opinion once I get a breath to review the footage and any other footage that may be archived within the staff evidence vaults. But toxicity should not play a factor here, speedie has had half a year to grow up and change. I've seen worse attitudes improve significantly over that time.

+0 until I review the footage, just want to guide discussion to the hacking aspect for now

Agree to disagree on this point, Whilst a Ban request has to be for the reasons stated (hacking) and nothing else, The Unban looks at everything, past behaviour, past bans, reason bans, other issues.

Im a -1. If this ban was just for toxicity then i would say yes to the unban. But it is for hacking, which should never be unbanned. Altho some say this evidance is shit, and yes it is. I wish there was better personally I believe you were hacking.