[tiefling lesbian]

In my opinion, it's not fair to play on a server for hours and then suddenly be told you have to change your name because someone with the same name connected way after you even though you've been using that name for years. I get that it's frustrating if someone can't use their regular name because a guest joined first, but this feels like the less unfair of the two options.
Again, just my opinion, which doesn't necessarily mean things can't be changed.

Also to clarify my opinion a bit, this would not apply if one player had only recently changed their name to it after playing on the server and knowing someone uses that name, but in this case both players have had the name for years