[Gabe]

What did I say that was anti-semitic? Dumb shit I said besides that, you're all using whataboutism right now. Nobody here has any solid reason or proof or even direct quotes of what I said, it's all just "I don't like this guy because he did X and got punished for it". I got punished, I don't say that stuff anymore.

I don't remember what you said nor do I have proof of it, I just remember it happening and you being gagged. I shared this along with other behaviors I have seen just to highlight my first hand experiences with you being gagged for something, as this is a request to be unpermagagged and I said what I said because I personally believe it's best to have the past issues such as the forum/discord punishments brought up while considering this request so that it's noted. I don't know why you were permagagged so I don't have any comment on that, hopefully someone can post the actual quotes or proof, But I do trust that the reason was valid for the permagag for the record. I -1ed based off the witness statements, past issues, and because I have never seen you acknowledge fault for anything or say how you'd change those behaviors.

As for forum toxicity, I would also like for "proof" to be posted. I just went through all his posts and none of them are remotely toxic. Were the toxic posts deleted? That might make more sense.

I'm also going to add some screenshots where, I believe the reaction to BirdDog's replies on the forums were actually toxic, versus what he posted. It helps paint the idea that in general people (in my opinion undeserving) don't like BirdDog, driving this bias. The reply below, wasn't toxic by any means but still got a negative reaction (despite the fact that BirdDog was 100% correct lol)

Just going to provide some context for the forum toxicity since jax brought it up. Yes, some of them were deleted. Others were not. Birddog(known as Ultramarine at the time) was banned for 1 week for continuously posting comments to stir up drama and were unnecessarily toxic for what was being replied to. I'll post some examples below.

From this thread. A serious discussion was taking place and Birddog said this. There is absolutely no reason for this to be said, especially while topics like sexual harassment are actively being discussed. This comment, intentionally or unintentionally, looked like it was meant to stir up drama for the reasons why Lemon resigned and what was being discussed in the comments above.

The next screenshots are deleted comments from this thread(another resign thread & this is whatresulted in the one week ban). It's pretty self-explanatory about how it was toxic and meant to stir up drama. 







Just throwing this one in here too, since it could swing either way with intent considering the other posts. This was on a donor abuse thread