[Wrong]

Definitely not abuse, but man are these replies something else. Try not to start an argument in the replies so staff doesn't have to sort through the mess when they handle the report, please? I don't mean to speak for them, but I know I'd be annoyed scrolling through this crap if I were them.

It's pretty clear that you KOSed Caribou for, as others have pointed out, "not shooting Zonda", which.... isn't KOSable...
Refraining from a firefight is not a traitorous act. Caribou could not have known if either of you were a T, or which of you if so.
Your claim that he was not IDing bodies has clearly been tacked on later in an attempt to make your claim seem more valid.

Damien did not mishandle these reports. He recognized that Zonda started the firefight without reason, but that you killed Caribou without a reason. Handing you a slay was correct.
Additionally, do you really think someone should be demoted for 1 mishandled report, had that actually been the case? I'd suggest that next time something upsets you, simply take a step away from your computer and take a deep breath. There's no reason to get worked up and come to the forums angry about it.

It was not tacked on. I called a valid KOS on Zonda for shooting me and not identifying bodies. Refusing to participate in a firefight is completely valid, but refusing to kill someone who is KOSed for both a valid reason AND a reason that Caribou himself witnessed is absolutely traitorous.

You actually can't kos someone for this. One of the rules on the server is that nobody is compelled to do any action, even if it is incredibly obvious. Caribou could've seen Zondaa kill innos in front of him and revive a t buddy, and he's not obligated to do anything.